Comparison of Steel and Reinforced Concrete Frames’ Durability under Fire and Post-Earthquake Fire Scenario

Document Type : Research Papers


1 babol noshirvani university of technology

2 Babol Noshirvani University of Technology

3 babol noshirvani university oftechnology


Two fire accidents took place in the Plasco Tower in Iran and Grenfell Tower of London in 2017. Although both of them have led to human tragedies, post-earthquake fire can cause more irreparable damages and catastrophes in larger extents. Engineering structures are subjected to different loads during their lifetime, which may cause damage or secondary loading effects. Evaluation of durability and stability of fired structures and the effects of seismic loading are considered to be significant parameters in fire engineering. The aim of this study is to evaluate and compare durability of reinforced concrete and steel frames during fire loading and post-earthquake fires. In this study, two 7-story steel and reinforced concrete frames are exposed to the fire load. At first, steel and concrete sections are put under various thermal loads in order to compare the method of their heat transfer. Then, the effects of crack on heat transfer of concrete sections are studied. Afterwards, the selected frames are exposed to the fire and post-earthquake fires. The results indicated that cracking and strength reduction due to seismic loading can decrease the durability of reinforced concrete frame in post-earthquake fire scenarios. However, the durability of steel frames has no significant relationship with the seismic loading and their durability are almost the same in the fire and post-earthquake fire scenarios.


Ali, A.S. and Hasan, T.M. (2020). “Flexural behavior of fiber reinforced self-compacting rubberized concrete beams”, Journal of Engineering, 26(2), 111-128.
Barkavi, T. and Naratarajan, C. (2019). “Processing digital image for measurement of crack dimensions in concrete”, Civil Engineering Infrastructures Journal, 52(1), 11-22. 
Elhami Khorasani, N. and Garlock, M.E.  (2017). "Overview of fire following earthquake: Historical events and community responses", International Journal of Disaster Resilience in the Built Environment, 8(2), 158-174.
Eskandari, M., Rahimian, M., Mahmoodi, A. and Ardeshir, A. (2013). “Analytical solution for two-dimensional coupled Thermo-elasto-dynamics in a cylinder”, Civil Engineering Infrastructures Journal, 46(2), 107-123.
Felicetti, R. and Gambarova, G. (1996). "Residual mechanical properties of high-strength concretes subjected to high-temperature cycles”, 4th    International Symposium on Utilization of High-Strength/High-Prformance Concrete, Paris, pp.  579-588.
Imani, R. and Mosqueda, G. (2014). "Experimental study on post-earthquake fire resistance of ductile concrete-filled double-skin tube columns", Journal of Structural Engineering, 141(8), 04014192.
Kadir, A. and Zhang, J. (2012). "Modeling of an earthquake damaged RC frame subjected to fire”, Proceedings of 7th International Conference on Structures in Fire, U.K., pp. 479-488.
Keller, W.J. and Pessiki, S. (2012). "Effect of earthquake-induced damage to spray-applied fire-resistive insulation on the response of steel moment-frame beam-column connections during fire exposure", Journal of Fire Protection Engineering, 22(4), 271-299.
Keller, W.J. and Pessiki, S. (2015). "Effect of earthquake-induced damage on the sidesway response of steel moment-frame buildings during fire exposure", Earthquake Spectra, 31(1), 273-292.
Khorasani, N.E. and Garlock, M. (2014). "Fire load: Survey data, recent standards, and probabilistic models for office buildings", Engineering Structures, 58(2), 152-165.
Kotsovinos, P. and Usmani, A. (2013). "The World Trade Center 9/11 disaster and progressive collapse of tall buildings", Fire Technology, 49(3), 741-765.
Lee, S.W. and Davidson, R.A.  (2010). "Physics-based simulation model of post-earthquake fire spread", Journal of Earthquake Engineering, 14(5), 670-687.    
Liu, G.-R. and Song, Y.P. (2010). "Post-fire cyclic behavior of reinforced concrete shear walls", Journal of Central South University of Technology, 17(5), 1103-1108.
Lowes, L.N. and Altoontash, A. (2003). "Modeling reinforced-concrete beam-column joints subjected to cyclic loading", Journal of Structural Engineering, 129(12), 1686-1697.
Memari, M. and Mahmoud, H. (2014). "Post-earthquake fire performance of moment resisting frames with reduced beam section connections", Journal of Constructional Steel Research, 103(2), 215-229.
Moradi, M., Tavakoli, H.R. and Abdolahzade, G.  (2019). "Sensitivity analysis of the failure time of reinforcement concrete frame under postearthquake fire loading", Structural Concrete, 21(1), 625-641.
Moradi, M. and Tavakoli, H.R. (2019). "Probabilistic assessment of failure time in steel frame subjected to fire load under progressive collapses scenario", Engineering Failure Analysis, 102(1), 136-147.
Natesh, P.S. and Agarwal, A. (2020). “Numerical Modelling of continuous composite beam under fire loading”, Advances in Structural Engineering, 74(1), 73-88.
Nishino, T. and Tanaka, T. (2012). "An evaluation method for the urban post-earthquake fire risk considering multiple scenarios of fire spread and evacuation", Fire Safety Journal, 54(2), 167-180.
Schar, Y.M. and Dancy, A.N. (2020). ” Assessment of reinforced concrete slabs post-fire performance”, Fire Safety Journal,  111(1), 102932.
Sharma, U.K. and Bhargava, P. (2012). "Full-scale testing of a damaged reinforced concrete frame in fire", Structures and Buildings, 165(7), 335-346.
Tan, Q.H., Garden, L., Han, H. and Song, T. (2020). “Performance of concrete-filled stainless steel tubular (CFSST) columns after exposure to fire”, Thin-Walled Structures, 146(3), 106629.
Tavakoli, H. and Afrapoli, M.M. (2018). "Robustness analysis of steel structures with various lateral load resisting systems under the seismic progressive collapse", Engineering Failure Analysis, 83(5), 88-101.
Tavakoli, H.R. and Kiakojuri, F. (2015). “Threat-independent column removal and fire-induced progressive collapse: Numerical study and comparison”, Civil Engineering Infrastructures Journal, 48(1), 121-131.
Usmani, A. and Zhang, J. (2012). "Using opensees for structures in fire", Journal of Structural Fire Engineering, 3(1), 57-70.
Wen, B., Zhang, L., Wu, B. and Niu, D. (2020). “High-temperature performance of damaged reinforced concrete columns under post-earthquake fires”, Structure and Infrastructure, 10(1), 1-5.
Wong, M. and Ghojel, J.I. (2003). "Sensitivity analysis of heat transfer formulations for insulated structural steel components", Fire Safety Journal, 38(2), 187-201.
Zolfaghari, M. and Peyghaleh, E. (2009). "Fire following earthquake, intra-structure ignition modeling", Journal of Fire Sciences, 27(1), 45-79.